BLOG

Define "spam"

A comment came through recently from Trent asking me to define spam. It’s been a while since I’ve talked about how I define spam, so let’s look at it.
Personally, I describe spam as unsolicited bulk email. If I didn’t ask for it and it looks like bulk mail then I consider it spam. In many cases the spammers have multiple email addresses of mine so I can demonstrate the mail was sent in bulk.
In my consulting and working with clients, though, I rarely use the word spam. There are so many different definitions of spam, I have no way to know if my clients understand what I am saying, so I avoid the term as much as humanly possible. An example of some of the few definitions of spam I’ve seen used over the years.

  • unsolicited bulk email
  • unsolicited commercial email
  • mail I don’t want
  • mail I don’t think my customers want
  • mail that is identical/similar to mail that hit my spamtrap
  • mail that was sent to a non-existent address at my domain
  • mail that contains HTML
  • unsolicited email
  • mail that advertises Viagra or porn sites or similar
  • mail that other people send

With my clients we talk about how the client’s mail is perceived by the various groups and why their mail might be blocked or filtered. For those cases, it’s useful to look at the definitions used by organizations doing the blocking.
Spamhaus and some other blocking lists use “unsolicited bulk email” as their definition. Many of the listings rely on mail to spamtraps. IPs sending mail to addresses not given to anyone, are sending unsolicited and presumably bulk mail. Thus that IP gets listed. They also have other lists that monitor snowshoe behaviour as well as listing domains. Spamhaus, and other blocklists believe that if a mailer is sending one piece of email to a user who did not request it, then they are likely mailing many other users who did not request any mail. This definition centers around permission, and any mail without permission is considered spam.
Many of the large ISPs use “mail our users complain about” as their definition. With this definition, they do not have to argue permission status with a sender. The data shows that their customers complain about mail from that sender or with that URL. The ISPs are going to block, or deliver to the bulk folder, email that their users do not want.
Filters and some blocking lists use “mail that has characteristics of mail we know is unsolicited bulk mail” as their definition. These characteristics can be things like an invalid HELO string, or lack of reverse DNS on the connecting IP address, or badly formatted HTML. Mail that looks like spam, in the technical sense, is often treated like spam.
Spam is a term that means different things to almost everyone. However, to answer your request, Trent: when I mention spam here on the blog without an accompanying explanation of the term, I’m talking about unsolicited bulk email.
This post is an updated version of  What really is spam, anyway?. I also talk about the definition of spam in Defining Spam

8 comments

  1. Mickey Chandler's Spamtacular | Email is about relationships says

    […] unfortunately, the receiving community isn’t helping. As Laura Atkins points out: Many of the large ISPs use “mail our users complain about” as their definition. With this […]

  2. Mickey Chandler's Spamtacular | Email is about relationships says

    […] unfortunately, the receiving community isn’t helping. As Laura Atkins points out: Many of the large ISPs use “mail our users complain about” as their definition. With this […]

  3. Mickey Chandler's Spamtacular | Email is about relationships says

    […] unfortunately, the receiving community isn’t helping. As Laura Atkins points out: Many of the large ISPs use “mail our users complain about” as their definition. With this […]

  4. Mickey Chandler's Spamtacular | Email is about relationships says

    […] unfortunately, the receiving community isn’t helping. As Laura Atkins points out: Many of the large ISPs use “mail our users complain about” as their definition. With this […]

  5. Mickey Chandler's Spamtacular | Email is about relationships says

    […] unfortunately, the receiving community isn’t helping. As Laura Atkins points out: Many of the large ISPs use “mail our users complain about” as their definition. With this […]

  6. Mickey Chandler's Spamtacular | Email is about relationships says

    […] unfortunately, the receiving community isn’t helping. As Laura Atkins points out: Many of the large ISPs use “mail our users complain about” as their definition. With this […]

  7. Mickey Chandler's Spamtacular | Email is about relationships says

    […] unfortunately, the receiving community isn’t helping. As Laura Atkins points out: Many of the large ISPs use “mail our users complain about” as their definition. With this […]

  8. The Received Blog says

    […] the quest for a more precise definition gets in the way. There’s no better example than the definition of spam, which has been argued for more than sixteen years even though there’s never been any […]

Comment:

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.