I’m doing testing on a new release of Abacus at the moment, so I’m in a software QA (Quality Assurance) frame of mind.
One of the tenets of software QA is “Assume users are malicious”. That’s also one of the tenets of security engineering, but in a completely different way.
A security engineer treats users as malicious, as the users he or she is most concerned about are crackers trying to compromise their system, so they really are malicious. A QA engineer knows that if you have enough users in the field, making enough different mistakes or trying to do enough unusual things, they’ll find all the buggy little corners of your application eventually – and crash it or corrupt data more reliably than a genuinely malicious user.
As a QA engineer it’s easier to personify the forces of chaos you’re defending against as a single evil weasel than a million random monkeys.
In the bulk email world the main points where you interact with your users are signup, confirmation, unsubscription and click-throughs. Always think about what the evil weasel will do at that point.
- The weasel will enter an invalid email address – check it at signup time
- The weasel will enter a valid email address that belongs to someone else – there are many ways to defend against that, none of them clearly the best
- The weasel will enter leading or trailing spaces – strip ’em off
- The weasel will enter non-ASCII characters in their name – and that’s OK unless it breaks your data handling
- The weasel will enter non-ASCII characters in their email address – and that’s probably not OK, not yet, anyway
- If you treat a character as “magic” anywhere in your data flow (whether that be a quote, a comma, tab or even a newline) your weasel will sneak it in to their data somewhere – always sanitize your inputs as soon as possible
- The weasel will sign up multiple times, in different places – yet they don’t really want multiple emails
- The weasel has a million email addresses, and will sign them all up if you send him a million tchotchkes to do that – don’t incentivize that sort of behaviour
- The weasel has, inexplicably, a thousand friends and will sign them all up if you send him a thousand tchotchkes to do so – which could conceivably be what you want, but be very, very sure before incentivizing for it
- The weasel surely has the email addresses of 100,000 strangers who he’ll tell you are his friends – be very careful about offering incentives for signups, as the weasel will happily have you send 99,999 pieces of unwanted spam so that he gets his nickel for the one recipient who buys from you
- The weasel will run antivirus software that automatically prefetches everything in the email – either have your “yes I want to subscribe” link go to a page that requires additional action, or have a “hidden” link in the email that invalidates the opt-in link if it’s followed
- The weasel will visit the confirmation link multiple times, and will complain if it welcomes them to the list each time – consider “You’re already subscribed to…” type language, if they’re already subscribed
- The weasel will edit the URL the opt-in link goes to, changing the email address embedded in it – so make sure that it’s an opaque token or cryptographically signed
- If the opt-in link contains the number 10237, the weasel will also go to the same URL with the number 10236 or 10238 – make sure that they can’t affect other peoples signups that way
- The weasel will sign up for your list, then unsubscribe, then six months later find the old confirmation email and click on the opt-in link – make sure that doesn’t work, instead routing them to a signup page, perhaps
- Your weasel doesn’t know their email address – make sure they don’t need to know it to unsubscribe
- Your weasel does know other peoples email addresses – make sure they need to know more than that to unsubscribe other people
- The weasel will run antivirus software that prefetches URLs in the email – so either require them to hit a button on the destination webpage or have a “hidden” link in the email that invalidates the opt-out link if it’s followed
- The weasel will hit the “this is spam” link to unsubscribe – make sure that doing that does suppress mail to them
- The weasel will appear almost intentionally stupid in their inability to navigate the complexities of your unsubscription mechanism – make sure that they can contact a human, and that that human has the power to suppress mail to them
- The weasel will share the email you send them with other people, who’ll then click on the unsubscription link – give them the email address on the unsubscription page, so they’re less likely to inadvertently unsubscribe the original weasel
- The weasel won’t remember their username or password – so don’t make them log in to see the content you link to from the email
- The weasel will forward your email on to other people – so make sure the other people can’t see any of the weasel’s PII or spend the weasel’s money without more authentication
- The weasel will click on the links in the email repeatedly – so make sure that’s OK
- The weasel will suddenly find email you sent them three years ago, and expect the links to still work
- The weasel will try to copy and paste URLs from the text part of your email – so try and keep them under 70 characters or so
There are countless other things the evil weasel and the random monkeys will do to throw a spanner into your systems. Bear them in mind when you’re putting infrastructure, or a campaign, or policies together.
What antivirus software prefetches all the URLs in emails?
That’s just insane.
Rumor has it that Trend was doing that, and that it might account for their problems with “spamtraps” that confirm subscriptions to COI newsletters. (wry grin) I’m not a Trend customer, so am not in a position to verify or discredit this rumor.
Ya know, years ago I was at a trade show. It was when everyone was on dialup. There were some guys there giving out floppy disks that prefetched all the links on a site while you looked at it.
The guy proudly handed me his floppy disk. “makes it all faster” he said. I asked why the heck anyone would want to prefetch all the links, even links it hasn’t been shown anyone at all would click on?
I said that would probably make everything slower, not faster. He said “we never thought of that”.
Here’s another reason not to do that sort of nonsense.
Um, that’s a bit different.