BLOG

Spam is not illegal

I was recently taken to task for claiming that unsolicited bulk email was spam.

Spam is illegal and Spammers are criminal. Let’s not mess about with words here. Calling someone a spammer is inflamitory [sic].

I’m not arguing that sending unsolicited bulk email is anything other than bad. And that a lot of senders have a negative reaction to being called spammers. I’ve even had hate mail for saying that an ISP was blocking mail because recipients were saying the mail was spam.

In the US, though, spam is not illegal. Violating CAN SPAM is illegal and may result in civil or criminal penalties. Sending mail to recipients that never gave permission? Not illegal.

Is there a lot of spam out there that violates CAN SPAM? Absolutely. But that’s not the sum total of email. In fact, that’s very little of the email that recipients actually see. ISPs and filtering companies do a pretty good job at filtering out most of the illegal stuff.

There is a lot of social pressure to not be perceived as a spammer. There is much social pressure to not send mail people like.

And, yes, there are countries where it is illegal to send mail without opt-in permission. Ironically, one of those countries is the UK. Marketers in the UK have 3 or 4 of my email addresses and frequently send me unsolicited email, in violation of their laws. I’ve even blogged about some of it.

Comment:

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • AOL compromise

    Lots of reports today of a security problem at AOL where accounts are sending spam, or are being spoofed in spam runs or something. Details are hazy, but there seems to be quite a bit of noise surrounding this incident. AOL hasn't provided any information as of yet as to what is going on.4 Comments


  • ReturnPath on DMARC+Yahoo

    Over at ReturnPath Christine has an excellent non-technical summary of the DMARC+Yahoo situation, along with some solid recommendations for what actions you might take to avoid the operational problems it can cause.No Comments


  • AOL problems

    Lots of people are reporting ongoing (RTR:GE) messages from AOL today.  This indicates the AOL mail servers are having problems and can't accept mail. This has nothing to do with spam, filtering or malicious email. This is simply their servers aren't functioning as well as they should be and so AOL can't accept all the mail thrown at them. These types of blocks resolve themselves. 1 Comment


Archives