Asking for help with a blocklist
There are often questions arising about how to go about getting off a particular blocklist. A few years ago I led the MAAWG effort to document what to if if you were On a Blocklist (pdf link). That document was aimed primarily at MAAWG members and deliverability experts with working knowledge of blocklists. I think, even now, it’s a good background on how to deal with a listing and mail being blocked.
There have been discussions on multiple mailing lists over the last week or so about how to deal with listings at different blocklists. Many folks on these lists have extensive experience, so these are good places to ask. With that being said, a lot of the requests lack sufficient details to help.
So, if you’re ever on a blocklist and want some help from a mailing list about the problem, here’s a short guide for how to ask for help.
- Keep the request short and concise. We don’t need 14 paragraphs about a business or how long a poster has been doing mail. Focus instead on details that people are going to need to answer the question.
- Tell them which blocklist. “Listed by Spamhaus” isn’t a useful statement. Spamhaus runs almost half a dozen lists, all with different listing criteria. “A domain blocklist” isn’t helpful, there are dozens of lists, all with different criteria. Getting delisted on the DBL is different from getting delisted by URIBL. State the specific list involved.
- Include the IP address. Most people people try and hide their IP address, limiting the amount of help anyone, including the blocklist folks, can give. Those folks who finally admit the IP often find very helpful answers from list members. On some lists, folks run spamtraps and are happy to share data from those feeds, even if they’re not involved in the listings.
- Include full bounce messages, if you have them. The messages sent during a rejected SMTP transaction are full of information about why a message was rejected. “Blocked with 554 at AOL” doesn’t tell anyone that much. “Blocked with 554 RLY:B1” at AOL tells us a lot more. Including the full message will save a lot of time in tracking down the information.
- Include how long this has been going on. A listing that’s been up for a few weeks is different than a listing that’s been up for months. Likewise, if the listing goes away and comes back, say that.
- Include what you’ve done to resolve it. Stating the steps already means new ideas, not the stuff already tried.
- Challenge the legality of blocklists. IP based blocking using public sources of data is 2 decades old at this point. They are a part of the email ecosystem. What few cases have been brought against blocklists have reinforced their legality.
- Get personal. This isn’t about a particular individual. All the lists used by the large mail providers are run by teams. Sometimes they are small teams, but they are teams.
- Argue the mail isn’t spam. It may or may not be, but these arguments can go on and on and only delay actual help in the delisting process. Also, some blocklists don’t list for spam, so the argument becomes even more pointless.
If a blocklist is in wide enough use that a listing is causing delivery problems, there are a couple things this says about the list.
- It blocks enough bad mail to be useful
- It doesn’t block much good mail.
- The policies for listing and delisting are supported by the receivers using the list.
- True listing errors are corrected quickly.
There are, maybe, a dozen lists that are used widely enough to significantly affect delivery of email. There are hundreds of other lists that are less widely used. I tell clients to not worry about being on a list unless it’s actively causing delivery problems. Yes, I use some of the online tools that check hundreds of lists. But just being listed doesn’t mean there’s a problem. Likewise, folks who are on no blocklist can still have delivery problems at major providers across the net.
Word to the Wise provides delisting assistance as part of our consulting program. If you’re having problems with a blocklist and need advice, feel free to contact us.