SpamCannibal is dead

The SpamCannibal blacklist – one that didn’t affect your email too much but which would panic users who found it on one of the “check all the blacklists!” websites – has gone away.
It was silently abandoned by the operator at some point in the past year and the domain registration has finally expired. It’s been picked up by domain squatters who, as usual, put a wildcard DNS record in for the domain causing it to list the entire internet.
Al has more details over at dnsbl.com.
If you run a blacklist, please don’t shut it down this way. Read up on the suggested practice in RFC 6471. If you just can’t cope with that consider asking people you know in the industry for help gracefully shutting it down.
Blacklist health checks
If you develop software that uses blacklists, include “health check” functionality. All relevant blacklists publish records that show they’re operating correctly. For IP based blacklists that means that they will always publish “127.0.0.2” as listed and “127.0.0.1” as not listed. You should regularly check those two IP addresses for each blacklist and if 127.0.0.1 is listed or 127.0.0.2 isn’t listed immediately disable use of that list (and notify whoever should know about it).
For IPv6 blacklists the always listed address is “::FFFF:7F00:2” and the never listed address is “::FFFF:7F00:1”. For domain-based blacklists the always listed hostname is “TEST” and the never listed hostname is “INVALID”. See RFC 5782 for more details. (And, obviously, check that the blacklists your software supports out of the box actually do implement this before turning it on).
If you use someone else’s blacklist code, ask them about their support for health checks. If your mail filter doesn’t use them you risk either suddenly having all your mail go missing (for naive blacklist based blocking) or having some fraction of wanted mail being delivered to your spam folder (for scoring based filters).

Related Posts

Fake DNSBLs

Spamhaus recently announced a few years ago that they have discovered a company that is pirating various blocklists, relabeling them and selling access to them. Not only is the company distributing the zones, they’re also running a “pay to delist” scheme whereby senders are told if they pay money, they’ll be removed from the lists.
The fake company does remove the listing from the fake zones, but does nothing to remove the IP from the original sender. This company has been caught in the past and was blocked from downloading Spamhaus hosted zones in the past, but have apparently worked around the blocks and are continuing to pirate the zone data.
It’s not clear how many customers the blocklist has, although one ESP rep told me they were seeing bounces referencing nszones.com at some typo domains.
No legitimate DNSBL charges for delisting. While I, and other people, do consult for senders listed on the major blocklists, this is not a pay for removal. What I do is act as a mediator and translator, helping senders understand what they need to do to get delisted and communicating that back to the blocklist. I work with senders to identify good, clean addresses, bad address segments and then suggest appropriate ways to comply with the blocklist requirements.

Read More

Reading between the lines

Reading between the lines an important skill in deliverability.
Why? Over the last few years there’s been an increasing amount of collaboration between deliverability folks at ESPs and ISPs. This is great. It’s a vast improvement on how things were 10 years ago. However, there are still ongoing complaints from both sides. There probably always will be. And it’s not like a blog post from me is going to fix anything. But I see value in talking a bit about how we can improve our ability to collaborate with one another.

Read More

Five-Ten blacklist retired

The Five-Ten website has a notice that they have retired the blacklist. Five-Ten wasn’t the greatest list for blocking mail, they aggressively listed senders and there were a number of false positives against a standard mail stream. But it was useful as a touchpoint. If I had a client that wasn’t listed on Five-Ten that told me something about their normal practices.

Read More